Forumsee logo
Forumsee » Cars » Brands and models » Read message
RSS: Subscribe to RSS

BMW - Solved P0171, P0174 and other fault codes by replacing K&N filter with OEM

1996 - 2003 (E39) - Bimmerforums - The Ultimate BMW Forum - forums.bimmerforums.com
vehicle: 2002 530i e39

Short Version: Constant fault codes (P0171, P0174 and others) related to lean mix, O2 sensors, MAF, etc. Thought the problem was downstream of intake. It wasn't. My K&N air filter was letting in too much air; replaced it with a quality OEM and codes went away and performance and mileage improved dramatically.

Long Version: Ever since purchasing my 2002 530i I've had nearly constantP0171, P0174 and other codes all associated with lean fuel/air mix in one wayor other.

- I cleaned, then replaced my MAF; performance improved a bitthen the codes returned.

- Ran a ton of cleaner through system, a little better butstill the codes.

- Replaced a cracked vacuum line, same thing.

Finally, checked for vacuum leaks with carb cleaner method -found a very small leak around VANOS but nothing major. Left the 02 sensors alone.

I didn't stop to consider that "lean" means itsgetting or detecting too much air and I also assumed that the problem must besomething involving or downstream from MAF.

SOLUTION: Upstream from MAF was my K&N air filter whichis designed to let in more air than the OEM that the various meters aredesigned to read.

So as a last resort before taking car in to the shop I replaced my K&N with a standard air filter (Purolator One). It was life changing! The car immediately improved: idle smoothedout, acceleration was more responsive, even vibrations coming from motor wentaway. And, the codes all cleared ontheir own. That is, in my case the K&N hurt performance.

Looking back at my previous BMWs, a 95 e38 and 98 e38, thesame problems persisted.

Might not work for your car but if you have some version ofa cold air intake, non-spec air filter etc and have not paired it with thecorrect MAF (for example, a Dinan CAI with a Dinan MAF) try spending $20 buckson a standard filter before wasting weekends chasing codes.

A final question as I close this long chapter: If"cold" air intakes are supposed to deliver more power, how comemotors don't generate more power in the winter compared to summer or eveningsvs day?

Press on regardless,

Ice Planter
Date: Oct 13, 2017    Labels: BMW


Last videos:

Are you getting the ZR1?
Are you getting the ZR1?
How to remove Heater Core on a 1963, Video
How to remove Heater Core on a 1963, Video
How to remove Heater Core on a 1963, Video
How to remove Heater Core on a 1963, Video
MCL Ride-Alongs: New Segment on my YouTube Channel
MCL Ride-Alongs: New Segment on my YouTube Channel
1981 factory footage
1981 factory footage
ZR1 On Track
ZR1 On Track
Check This Fast N' Loud Find!
Check This Fast N' Loud Find!
Has this been posted before now?
Has this been posted before now?

Tags

Cars ·
Travel ·
Pets ·
production-frontend